Sunday, April 26, 2009

How Group Decisions Can End up Wrong!

How Investment Committees Go Amiss - WSJ.com

Jason Zweig, in his column, The Intelligent Investor, points out that financial decisions made by committees, are often bad decisions. His advice applies to all kinds of decisions.
  • Measure what factors predict success.
  • Rank the people (and rank the ideas) using metrics.
  • Reframe the question. Develop arguments "pro" and "con".
  • Ask "the five whys". Why is the idea superior? Why is this the 'right" answer? Why...?, Why...? Why...?
  • Define the default position. Any deviation from the default should require extraordinary evidence.
Excellent advice for ANY decision making.

1 comment:

PD loft crew said...

http://bobsutton.typepad.com/my_weblog/2009/04/how-group-decisions-go-wrong-jason-zweig-in-the-wall-street-journal.html

Some extra back story from my old prof Bob

Ed